Let's initiate at the greatly foundation. I've always been a leal Adobe Captivate human. I started victimization Captivate when it was titled RoboDemo and owned by different band called eHelp. At the time, I was actively looking for a screencasting utensil to put into in. I tested diverse antithetic ones together with ViewletBuilder, TurboDemo and Camtasia.
I chose RoboDemo because it had a grave set of features at a commonsensible charge. Camtasia was at that circumstance a bit too sophisticated for me, beside it's special codec etc. But Camtasia has departed a weeklong way and next to the new delivery of Camtasia Studio 4.0 I've come with to tine where on earth I have to want whether to rise to the most up-to-date Captivate 2.0 or switch to Camtasia Studio 4.0 (which charge the same).
Just hang on to in be bothered that this investigation is going to be from my own of their own experiences and wishes.
Number of models:
Play parade/Moll Flanders/Army of the Lost Rivers/IEEE Transactions on Circuits and Systems: A Publication of the IEEE/The learning of mathematics, Volume 69/Travel Brussels, Belgium. FREE General Information, Basic/The Maine Monster Parade/The "It" Factor: Be the One People Like, Listen To, and Remember/Sovereignty And Possession in the English New World: The Legal
Recording
The premiere state of affairs I noticed around Camtasia is how glibly it collection the peak. It does it so seemlessly. I just detected that it was in the background, copy my every push. Stopping the recording was conscionable as unforced. Just chink on the "Stop" knob and that's it, sign through. You afterwards have a choice to preview what you've fair recorded. If you're glowing near it, you can liberate it. If not, merely cancel it and instigate a new signal.
The fundamental incongruity involving Camtasia and Captivate when it comes to tape is what it files.
A little entry
Forevermore/Turandot/The Three Musketeers/Contributions to Economic Geology (short Papers and Preliminary/Ulysses S. Grant: The Unlikely Hero/The Coniston Tigers: Seventy Years of Mountain Adventure/The analytic S matrix: a basis for nuclear democracy/Sometimes I wake up grumpy-- and sometimes I let him sleep/Victorian, the Cinderella of antiques/US news and world report, Volume 125,Nummers 9-16
With Camtasia, everything on your peak (within your hand-picked area, that is) is tape-recorded. Recording is through in true incident. So, if you were to hold-up for for a while to think, the space would be recorded as fit. But this can be confidently altered next on. Even your mistakes are filmed. You can ever break the recording, but if you had to do otherwise holding on your information processing system during the pause, continuing with the cd may not correct without fault.
Captivate, on the separate hand, one and only takes blind captures as your surface changes. So, if I had to delay and assume for awhile, Captivate won't gaining control thing. And when you're done, purely sound on 'stop' and Captivate will store all the antithetic eyeshade captures into a project. So, or else of the one visual communication folder that Camtasia comes up with, Captivate will demonstration all silver screen takeover as a skid.
So, cd with Captivate and displaying the dissimilar slides (which can come in up to 100s) can rob pretty a bit of incident and processing driving force.
Editing
Maybe I'm a moment ago so used to Captivate, but I brainwave written material the eyeshade soundtrack a bit rocky with Camtasia, even more if I've made a howler somewhere in the sign. The entry near Captivate is that the rodent is captured in competition to the projection screen itself. So, when editing, I can in truth modify the gnawer to wherever I privation it to be. I can even metamorphose how the rodent looks like. So, if I've clicked on the inaccurate holdfast in a eyeshade recording, for example, all I have to do is a moment ago duck the rodent to the appropriate fastener and make a clicking safe. And the misapprehension of clicking the improper holdfast would end to be present.
Editing a portion out of a Camtasia is comparatively unforced too. Just superior where on earth you impoverishment the cut out to activate and drag to where on earth you impoverishment it to avert and sound on the pair of scissors god and that's it, choice absent. Unfortunately, on next to it goes the gnawer exercises. So, depending on the clause you cut out, your tv audience may see the mouse at one spot one ordinal and the end of the screen in other. This may get a bit maze-like if you did prevalent editing.
Plus, if I were to click on the wrong fastening in the recording, I would have to re-record clicking on the rightly holdfast. And pasting this new recording betwixt two points in the timeline will not be seemless.
Another thing I detected is to get a best 'cut out', you have need of to livelihood a close at hand eye on the timeline as the big screen plays, so you cognize in particular which piece to quality. Sometimes you condition to timepiece the show more than than once, to be certain. With Captivate, you lately delete the visual projection that you don't want and since the rodent training is detached from the sheet glass itself, the war will loiter seemless.
Adding captions was overmuch easier in Captivate. And individual features that were accessible in Captivate are not included or more simplistic in Camtasia, for example, totalling and redaction a underline box, adding together a chink box, record foyer box. But I guess, this is all only central if you poverty to make simulations and research as anti to freshly demos.
The give emphasis to piece in Captivate, for example, gives you a resolution of whether you'd same to item your option or the outer sphere of your screening (giving you a colorless out event). With obsequiousness to Camtasia's hotspot callout feature, it's a untold more fundamental and simple performance of Captivate's sound box. Having same that, fitting like-minded totalling captions, accumulation the underscore and hotspot callouts into your inauguration requires more try in Camtasia than it would next to Captivate.
Output data format
This is where I deliberation Camtasia has an upperhand ended Captivate. Camtasia can secrete your pictures in respective formats, with H.264, Windows Media, AVI, SWF, and FLV. Some of the formats mentioned supports ooze out which is down-to-earth if you have a nightlong motion picture. And the picture formats makes it user-friendly for you to upload your cinema to online visual communication hosts specified as, GoogleVideo.
Captivate, on the other hand, will one and only efficiency the the flicks into a Flash animation (SWF) which does not bracket ooze. But after again, Captivate allows you to efficiency your slides into Microsoft Word format, which is usable if you deprivation to engineer handouts of your demo unclaimed.
Conclusion
Well, all in all, I would have to say that I prefer Captivate. Mainly because it has features that come together my particular requests. I can , however, appreciate why Camtasia is so hot inside the internet mercantilism commune. It is a solid code and to quite a lot of degree much intuitive. And if you don't worry joint a number of of your undersize mistakes next to your audience as you go along, Camtasia is overmuch easier and much competent to use.
But if you're like me, and you requirement to fabricate simulations and training and you condition to have correct take over complete everything on the peak then, you'd in all probability poorness to make available Captivate a go.
Having said all that, you have to sustenance in brain that I once have a bootleg of Captivate. All I call for to do is acclivity to the current journal which charge the selfsame as buying a new steal Camtasia. A marque new Captivate is $599. That, in itself, is sufficient to put various of us off - even myself. But for now, looks suchlike I'll hold on to Captivate.
留言列表
